From the Palatine to Pirro Ligorio: architectural, sculptural and antiquarian studies in memory of Amanda Claridge (1949-2022)
December 2023
|
Edited book
Virtue in variety: contrasting temple design in Etruscan Italy
July 2023
|
Chapter
|
Adoption, Adaption, and Innovation in Pre-Roman Italy: Paradigms for Cultural Change
This chapter will consider why temples with variants of peripteral and Tuscan plans were built side by side in select central Italic sanctuaries during the Etruscan Archaic period (c. 580-480 bce). The collocation of temples with starkly different plans, as exemplified at Pyrgi and Marzabotto, has often been read as a sign that a site underwent a phase of Hellenization in architecture, religion, or culture more generally. The juxtaposition has also been ascribed to the demands of unknown rituals. As excavations uncover more similarities between the sanctuaries of Pyrgi and Regio I at Marzabotto, however, potential explanations for this phenomenon should now evolve to include factors that connect both sites as well as other examples. This chapter will consequently suggest that the collocation of temple plans reflects a central Italic affinity for visual variety and competition, comparable to the delight in contrasting designs displayed later at sites like Largo Argentina in Rome. The result is a model in which the use of ‘Greek’ architectural styles in Etruria and Latium is explained with reference to local aesthetic preferences.
Investing in religion: religion and the economy in pre-Roman central Italy
June 2023
|
Chapter
|
Economics of Roman Religion
Studies of the role of religion in a range of pre-industrial economies make it possible, and helpful, to assess the distinctive elements of this subject in ancient Rome by comparison with practice elsewhere. This chapter accordingly surveys the economic significance of Etrusco-Italic sanctuaries in the period preceding the Roman Republic. Beyond providing an analogy for later centuries, however, it suggests that many of the economic aspects of Roman religion were actually shaped by developments in the Archaic period (c.580–480 bc). The characteristic features of Archaic sanctuaries developed in response to a combination of Mediterranean-wide and local circumstances, and arguably met the needs of their communities so successfully that they had a lasting influence on the form and function of their Roman counterparts. Together these factors turned religion, and particularly cult sites, into an economic force. Sanctuaries became privileged places for the exchange of tangible and intangible commodities, and may have established a template for the site and conduct of similar activities in fora and other spaces in the centuries that followed. As such these developments may go beyond providing a point of comparison for Republican and imperial practices by actually outlining their background and rationale: while the scale and complexity of the religious economy may have changed in the Roman period, the social, cultural, and theological elements of the underlying model may have not.
Questo contributo suggerisce che il deposito dei votivi nell’ Italia centrale antica
fosse una fonte di capitale sociale. Il rito ha forgiato relazioni tra i devoti e gli dei,
oltre che tra gli stessi devoti, relazioni che probabilmente hanno promosso la fiducia,
aumentato i sentimenti di sicurezza, e rafforzato i valori condivisi. Questi risultati
sociali potrebbero, a loro volta, aver accresciuto il potenziale economico delle
persone e delle comunità riducendo così i rischi, abbassando i costi delle transazioni,
e aumentando la sicurezza in se stessi. L’aumento degli investimenti nelle
infrastrutture sacre nel periodo arcaico per di più indicherebbe il modo in cui il culto
e il risultante capitale sociale contribuissero alla crescita di città e di stati e anche di
nuove idee della comunità.
FFR
Fora as urban sanctuaries: Continuities in form and function
July 2022
|
Conference paper
|
Archaeology and Economy in the Ancient World: Cities, Resources and Religion – Economic Implications of Religion in Graeco-Roman Urban Environments
FFR
Architecture in Ancient Central Italy: connections in Etruscan and early Roman Building
March 2022
|
Edited book
Architecture in Ancient Central Italy takes studies of individual elements and sites as a starting point to reconstruct a much larger picture of architecture in western central Italy as an industry, and to position the result in space (in the Mediterranean world and beyond) and time (from the second millennium BC to Late Antiquity). This volume demonstrates that buildings in pre-Roman Italy have close connections with Bronze Age and Roman architecture, with practices in local and distant societies, and with the natural world and the cosmos. It also argues that buildings serve as windows into the minds and lives of those who made and used them, revealing the concerns and character of communities in early Etruria, Rome, and Latium. Architecture consequently emerges as a valuable historical source, and moreover a part of life that shaped society as much as reflected it.
Introduction: Building connections
March 2022
|
Chapter
|
Architecture in Ancient Central Italy: Connections in Etruscan and Early Roman Building
This chapter serves as an introduction for what follows by placing the volume’s approach into the wider context of the past and current study of central Italic architecture. It points out some of the issues that underlie and join the subsequent analyses, including why so many major building projects were undertaken in Etruria, Rome, and Latium in this period, who and what was moving to create them, and how the results blur the boundaries of what has traditionally been considered ‘Roman’. Fundamentally, it argues not only for the value of central Italic architecture as a source for regional social and economic histories, but also for its potential contribution to the study of ancient architecture as a whole.
FFR
The theology of scale: monumental and miniature cult buildings in Archaic central Italy
January 2022
|
Chapter
|
(S)Proporzioni: Tagli e scala tra testo e immagine
The Etruscans: setting new agendas
October 2021
|
Journal article
|
Journal of Archaeological Research
The Etruscans, who dominated central Italy for much of the first half of the first millennium BC, are ripe for new analysis: the quantity of data for their culture is now substantial, wide ranging, and qualifies for large-scale comparison. In this paper, we survey how research in the last decade has affected our understanding of settlements, of changing models of the transfer of ideas, and of Etruscan religious behavior, among other topics. We place them into complex spatial, architectural, and economic narratives to show that the interplay between microhistorical case studies and macrohistorical trends has now achieved what ought to be a paradigmatic status. Despite the continuous flow of specialist publications and an industry of exhibitions, however, the Etruscans have not broken through into mainstream archaeological awareness. We argue that this could be achieved if future research becomes more thematic and agenda driven and embraces comparative study.
FFR
Made in Etruria: Recontextualising the ramo secco
March 2020
|
Journal article
|
American Journal of Numismatics
This paper reassesses the designs on the surface of ‘ramo secco’ ingots and proposes that the insignia had a meaningful role in Etruscan culture. Whereas the design has previously been held to be a utilitarian part of the manufacturing process with no iconographic value or, conversely, a deliberate attempt to represent tridents, lightning, or some type of plant without a clear rationale, this paper offers the alternative suggestion that the design was intended to represent growing wheat. This proposal links the ingots to the agrarian and mineral wealth of the Etruscans and may help to reconstruct the ingots’ role in the Etruscan economy.
Etruria (Italy), c. 900-300 BCE
May 2019
|
Chapter
|
Sir Banister Fletcher's Global History of Architecture
Religious Architecture in Latium and Etruria, c. 900-500 BC
November 2015
|
Book
Religious Architecture in Latium and Etruria c. 900-500 BC presents the first comprehensive treatment of cult buildings in western central Italy from the Iron Age to the Archaic Period.
Vitruvius and Etruscan design
January 2015
|
Journal article
|
Accordia Research Papers
It is all too tempting to use Vitruvius’ De architectura to reconstruct the walls and columns of Etruscan temples now missing from the archaeological record. The Roman treatise contains a clear formula for the ground plan of a temple designed in accordance with the tuscanicae dispositiones, but that plan differs from those of many Etruscan cult buildings reconstructed on the basis of archaeological evidence. This article explores the resulting debate about what Vitruvius was actually describing and by extension his relevance for the study of Etruscan architecture. It shows that while Vitruvius should not be regarded as an authoritative source of information about Etruscan plans, this is less a consequence of his measurements than the way in which they are often interpreted. If the discrepancies between the literary and archaeological data are regarded not as errors but as signs of the intended function of the tuscanicae dispositiones, then it is possible to reconcile the divergent evidence for the arrangement of temple walls and columns in a manner consistent with modern architectural theory.
The development and architectural significance of early Etrusco-Italic podia
January 2011
|
Journal article
|
BABESCH
The incorporation of podia into Etruscan and Latial religious buildings during the 6th century BC marks the emergence of temples as a distinct architectural form in both the urban landscape and the archaeological record. Consideration of the significance of this change in elevation, however, has largely been overlooked to date in preference for the presentation of podia as a Roman form derived from Etruscan sacred aesthetics. This review of the evidence for the chronological and geographical development of podia in central Italy will suggest a means of differentiating podia from other substructures, demonstrate that they can be recognised in Latium before Etruria, and argue that their introduction may represent an architectural response to particular local conditions.
SBTMR
The art of piety and profit at Pompeii: A new interpretation of the painted shop façade at ix.7.1–2
March 2009
|
Journal article
|
Greece and Rome
There are seventy-four catalogued examples of figured art painted on Pompeian façades, almost all of a religious or talismanic nature. This street art appeared near compital altars and entrances to shops and houses, and contributed to a vibrant street aesthetic. Exterior figured paintings have not received a great deal of scholarly attention, however, with studies tending to focus on iconography rather than considering how street art may have functioned in its original setting. The potential value of painted façades as evidence for religious, commercial, and civic values, for which there are scant literary sources, has consequently been overlooked.
SBTMR
An external view: architecture and ritual in central Italy
Chapter
|
The Stuff of the Gods: The Material Aspects of Religion in Ancient Greece